Strona główna / Recenzje / StoneX Trading
AD SPACE AVAILABLE Your banner can be here. Contact us for placement terms and conditions. Contact us →
RECENZJA BROKERA · POZYCJA #77 Z 139

Recenzja StoneX Trading

One of the UK's oldest spread-betting/CFD brands (founded 1983 by Chris Hales and Jonathan Sparke as City Index), acquired by GAIN Capital in 2014, which was in turn acquired by Nasdaq-listed StoneX Group in 2020. The City Index brand was formally retired in the UK on 12 September 2026 and replaced by StoneX Trading, with existing clients migrated and no change to accounts or platforms.

2.71 / 5 ogółem FCA No. 446717 · zał. 1983
Zbadał i zweryfikował fakty: GlobalFXHub Research Team Dane ostatnio zweryfikowane: 8 October 2026 Regulacja ostatnio zweryfikowana: 8 October 2026 Ceny ostatnio sprawdzone: March 2026 Następna planowana weryfikacja: January 2027
Warto wiedzieć: StoneX Trading is the direct successor to the City Index retail brand, renamed 9-12 September 2026 (same FCA entity, StoneX Financial Ltd, same accounts and platforms carried over -- not a new company). This entity is UK-retail-focused; the wider StoneX Group's other Tier-1 licences (NFA/CFTC in the US, ASIC in Australia, CIRO in Canada, MAS in Singapore, and CySEC in Cyprus via a separate entity trading as FOREX.com, also reviewed on this site) are held by separate sister entities within StoneX Group Inc. (Nasdaq: SNEX), not by this UK entity directly, so they are not counted toward this broker's regulation score. As a brand name, "StoneX Trading" is only weeks old at the time of this review, so independent public track record and reviews under this specific name are minimal.
Porównaj z innym brokerem Znajdź podobnych brokerów Verify on FCA register Odwiedź brokera
Regulowany podmiotStoneX Financial Ltd
RegulacjaFCA No. 446717
Inni regulatorzy Tier-1Żaden niepotwierdzony
Założony1983
SiedzibaLondon, UK (parent StoneX Group Inc. headquartered in New York, USA; Nasdaq: SNEX)
Minimalny depozytNiepotwierdzone niezależnie
Śr. spread (EUR/USD)Niepotwierdzone niezależnie
PlatformyMT4, Web Trader (proprietary), TradingView charting
InstrumentyIndices, shares, forex (85 pairs), and commodities, per StoneX's own UK "StoneX Trading" markets page; no crypto offering is listed there and no single total instrument count is published. Note: StoneX's separate FOREX.com brand advertises a much larger range including crypto -- a different brand/entity from this one.

Zobacz pełne dossier regulacyjne StoneX Trading → · How to check whether a forex broker is regulated

Zalety

  • Broad platform choice: MT4, Web Trader (proprietary), TradingView charting
  • Long operating history, trading since 1983

Wady

  • Thinner regulatory footprint than most peers on this list
  • Minimum deposit and/or EUR/USD spread could not be independently confirmed -- check current terms directly with the broker.

Szczegóły oceny

Regulacja i ochrona klienta
1.8 / 5
Koszty tradingu Za mało potwierdzonych danych, by ocenić
Opłaty niezwiązane z tradingiem
1 / 5
Platformy i narzędzia
3.4 / 5
Egzekucja / warunki tradingu
4 / 5
Zakres produktów
3.5 / 5
Depozyty i wypłaty
3 / 5
Przejrzystość
5 / 5
Historia działania
4.26 / 5

Dla kogo StoneX Trading jest -- a dla kogo nie jest -- dobrym wyborem

Prawdopodobnie dobry wybór, jeśli jesteś...

  • Traders who want platform choice -- 3 platforms are confirmed, including MT4, Web Trader (proprietary).
  • EU- and/or UK-based traders who want the regulatory protections and investor compensation scheme that come with a CySEC and/or FCA licence (see Investor protection below).

Poszukaj gdzie indziej, jeśli jesteś...

  • No specific "not for" signal in our researched criteria -- still confirm current terms directly with the broker.

Wynika z tych samych potwierdzonych danych, które stoją za oceną tego brokera (regulacja, koszt, platformy, minimalny depozyt) -- to nie jest osobna ocena redakcyjna.

Ochrona inwestora

Via its FCA-regulated UK entity, eligible clients are covered by the UK's Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) up to £85,000 per person if the firm fails.

Investor compensation schemes explained →

Konta, koszty i wsparcie -- szczegółowo

Poza głównym spreadem i minimalnym depozytem podanymi wyżej. Gdy nasze badania nie potwierdziły niezależnie konkretnego szczegółu, mówimy o tym otwarcie, zamiast zgadywać -- zweryfikuj bezpośrednio u brokera, zanim na tym polegasz.

Typy kontA Standard CFD/spread-betting account, an MT4 account, and an Elective Professional tier for qualifying high-volume clients.
Model egzekucjiIndependent reviewers (published under the former City Index name, before the September 2026 rebrand) describe it as operating an internal dealing desk/market-maker model, which they flag as a potential conflict of interest versus pure STP/ECN brokers. Low confidence
Wypłaty i depozytyCard minimum 100 units of the base currency, PayPal minimum 50 units, and no stated minimum for bank wire. All deposits and withdrawals are free of charge from the broker's side. Online withdrawals are capped at £20,000 per transaction, with processing taking 3-5 business days.
Finansowanie overnight (swap)Published formula: daily fee = position value times rate, divided by a 365- or 360-day basis depending on currency. The rate is a regional benchmark (e.g. SONIA for GBP, SOFR for USD, EUR short-term rate for EUR) plus or minus a 2.5% markup; FX pairs instead use standard swap points.
Koszt przewalutowaniaThe broker states that "commercially reasonable rates" apply to currency conversions, disclosed on contract notes and statements, but no flat percentage is published.
Opłata za nieaktywnośćSources disagree on the exact amount -- one cites £12/month after 12 months of no trading, another £10/month -- though both agree the fee is waived if the client trades during that period, and both describe it as a recurring source of user complaints. Low confidence
Obsługa klientaTrustpilot (under the former City Index name) rates it 4.3/5 from around 390 reviews, with 24/5 live chat support; the inactivity fee is the most commonly cited complaint.
Doświadczenie mobilneOne independent review site rates the app 4.5/5, ranking it 9th of 63 brokers reviewed for mobile trading -- though this and the reviews above predate the September 2026 rename and may not yet reflect the StoneX Trading brand specifically.
Oferta edukacyjnaHistorically ran a structured "Trading Academy" course series; current offering includes beginner and advanced videos, positioned as beginner-friendly.

Zobacz, jak koszt spreadu StoneX Trading wypada na tle wszystkich zbadanych brokerów → · Forex broker fees explained

Najczęściej zadawane pytania

Is StoneX Trading regulated?

Yes -- FCA No. 446717. See the regulation dossier on this page for the underlying licence numbers.

Is my money protected if StoneX Trading fails?

Via its FCA-regulated UK entity, eligible clients are covered by the UK's Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) up to £85,000 per person if the firm fails.

What is the minimum deposit at StoneX Trading?

Not independently confirmed in our research -- verify directly with the broker.

What trading platforms does StoneX Trading offer?

StoneX Trading offers MT4, Web Trader (proprietary), TradingView charting.

What is StoneX Trading's average spread on EUR/USD?

Not independently confirmed in our research -- verify directly with the broker.

When was StoneX Trading founded?

StoneX Trading was founded in 1983.

How is StoneX Trading's overall score calculated?

StoneX Trading currently scores 2.71/5 overall under our disclosed nine-category methodology -- regulation & client protection 30%, trading costs 20%, non-trading fees 10%, platforms & tools 10%, execution/trading conditions 10%, product range 5%, deposits/withdrawals 5%, transparency 5%, track record 5%. It is not a comparison to other brokers and not based on hands-on testing.

Jak obliczana jest ta ocena: Dziewięć ważonych kategorii według stałej, jawnej skali -- regulacja i ochrona klienta 30%, koszty tradingu 20%, opłaty niezwiązane z tradingiem 10%, platformy i narzędzia 10%, egzekucja/warunki tradingu 10%, zakres produktów 5%, depozyty/wypłaty 5%, przejrzystość 5%, historia działania 5% -- to nie ranking względem innych brokerów i nie praktyczny test konta. Zobacz pełną metodologię. Zweryfikuj aktualne warunki bezpośrednio u brokera i w publicznym rejestrze jego regulatora przed wpłaceniem środków. To nie jest zindywidualizowana porada finansowa.

Ostatnie zmiany

Datowany rejestr momentów, w których nasze własne opublikowane dane o tym brokerze faktycznie się zmieniły -- a nie zrekonstruowana historia tego, co zrobił sam broker. Zobacz pełny narzędzie rejestru zmian dla każdego brokera.

Żadne monitorowane pole (ceny, platformy, numery licencji) nie zmieniło się dla tego brokera od momentu, gdy zaczęliśmy je monitorować -- to nie to samo, co stwierdzenie, że nic nigdy się nie zmieniło u samego brokera, oznacza tylko, że nasze własne opublikowane dane nie wymagały jeszcze korekty.

Inni ocenieni brokerzy

#1 · 4.1 / 5

AvaTrade

EU clients typically served under Central Bank of Ireland / MiFID passporting rather than a direct CySEC CIF licence -- worth confirming which entity applies to you.

#2 · 4.08 / 5

Interactive Brokers

Publicly listed on Nasdaq (IBKR) and an S&P 500 constituent, Interactive Brokers is one of the largest electronic brokers globally by client equity, with access to 150+ markets worldwide. Founder Thomas Peterffy remains Chairman. Widely regarded as a low-controversy, Category-A-regulator-only broker relative to CFD-focused peers.

#3 · 4.01 / 5

ThinkMarkets

ThinkMarkets is a dual-headquartered (Melbourne/London) group founded in 2010 by brothers Nauman and Faizan Anees, in which each of its major-jurisdiction licences (FCA, ASIC, FSCA, DFSA, FMA) sits in a different legal entity from its CySEC-licensed European arm.